Search:
Filter results by:
Topic
Recommendations
Key Findings
Tasks
Questions we Asked
Issues
Stakeholders
Geographic Area

Search for the following document types:

Plan 2012 will be more robust and provide important benefits compared to Plan 77A



Details
In choosing to recommend Lake Superior Regulation Plan 2012, the Study Board developed and applied a number of decision criteria and other evaluation metrics. No single regulation plan developed during the plan formulation and evaluation process was uniquely superior to all the other plans – there were tradeoffs that were made by the Study Board between economic performance, reliability under extreme lake levels and ecological performance. In all instances, the differences in economic performance among the final set of plans was very small – well within the range of measurement error. As a result, the Study Board focused on the relatively small difference among plans regarding ecological metrics and performance under extreme conditions – conditions that might materialize under a variety of future climate-driven sequences. The ultimate driver for decisions became “which plan is the most robust”, and will perform the best under a range of extreme conditions. So while no plan outperformed every other plan for all nine decision criteria and NBS sequences, Lake Superior Regulation Plan 2012 was found to meet all the Study Board’s decision criteria and is considered to be more robust than Plan 1977A, performing better for most NBS sequences and never significantly worse, and providing benefits related to maintenance of Superior levels, the environment, economic benefits and ease of regulation
Related Projects
Impacts of Fluctuations in Levels and Flow Rates
Assessment of Present and Future Water Uses
Simulation of Consumptive Use Impacts on Water Levels
Water Uses Performance Indicators
Water Uses Synthesis and Summary
Electricity Price Forecasts
Hydropower Regression Relationships
Soo Headrace Canal Modelling
Hydropower Performance Indicators
Hydropower Synthesis and Summary
Commercial Navigation Contextual Narrative
GL-SAND Model
Commercial Navigation Performance Indicators
Commercial Navigation Summary
Rec Boating Literature Review & Marina Slip Field Measurements
Tourism Assessment as Influenced by Water Levels
Recreational Boating Performance Indicators
Recreational Boating Synthesis and Summary
Low Water Impact Analysis
Flooding Impact Analysis
Shore Protection Impact Analysis
Erosion Impact Analysis
Coastal Zone Performance Indicators
Coastal Zone Synthesis and Summary
Lake Superior Wild Rice
Black and Sturgeon Bay Bulrush Marsh
Lakes Superior & Michigan Wetland Invertebrates & Fish
Batchawana Bay Wetland Vegetation
Arcadia Meadow Marsh Vegetation
Lake Michigan-Huron Sediment-Water Phosphorus Flux
Georgian Bay Wetland Connectivity and Vegetation
Les Cheneaux Islands Wetland Vegetation
Saginaw Bay Wetland Vegetation
Saginaw Bay and Les Cheneaux Islands Macroinvertebrates
Saginaw Bay Wetland Fish
Lake St. Clair Wetland Fish
Long Point Wetland Vegetation and Fish
Long Point and Saginaw Bay Wetland Birds
Shared Vision Modelling
Lake Superior Plan Formulation
Image